A horrifying case out of Defiance County, Ohio, has resurfaced after a woman, previously convicted of forcing her 10-year-old stepson to kill his father, was granted a retrial. The shocking allegations paint a disturbing picture of psychological manipulation and abuse, leaving a community in disbelief.
A Tragic Death That Took Years to Unravel
The case dates back to 2003 when Robert Breininger was found dead from a gunshot wound. Initially ruled as a tragic accident, the case remained closed until nearly a decade later, when Breininger’s son, Corey, revealed a shocking truth—his stepmother, Judith Hawkey, had coerced him into pulling the trigger.
Corey, who was just 10 years old at the time of the shooting, later told a teacher that his stepmother physically and emotionally abused him, threatening severe punishment if he didn’t follow her orders. According to prosecutors, Hawkey allegedly manipulated the boy into believing he had no choice but to kill his father.
Conviction and Shocking Reversal
In 2013, a jury found Judith Hawkey guilty of aggravated murder and sentenced her to life in prison without parole. However, in 2016, the Third District Court of Appeals overturned the conviction, citing issues with evidence and concerns over the effectiveness of her defence.
Now, after being released on bond, Hawkey is awaiting retrial, reigniting public debate over the case and leaving many wondering whether justice will ultimately be served.
Community Reaction and Legal Questions
The case has left many in Ohio unsettled, as it raises difficult questions about the manipulation of children, domestic abuse, and the justice system. Corey’s revelation about the years of abuse and coercion he allegedly suffered before the murder has sparked discussions on how to protect vulnerable children from similar situations.
Legal experts note that the retrial could be challenging for prosecutors, as the case hinges on decades-old evidence and testimony. However, advocates insist that Corey’s story deserves to be heard again in court, and justice must be served.
What Happens Next?
With a new trial ahead, all eyes are on the court as Hawkey faces another legal battle. Prosecutors remain determined to prove their case, while the defence will fight to challenge the original evidence and conviction.
For now, the case remains a chilling reminder of how domestic violence and manipulation can have devastating consequences—and why ensuring protection for vulnerable children is more critical than ever.